The news that employees in monopoly sectors enjoy much higher
salaries than their counterparts in other sectors will be an issue
for some time, given the rising anti-monopoly sentiment
nationwide.
As the national labor regulation body revealed, the salary gap
between workers in monopolized and competitive industries is not
only stunningly big, but widening rapidly in recent years.
Many are wondering why those in monopoly sectors earn much more
just for working in that industry, and not for increased hours or
higher skill sets. Such a sentiment, if unresolved, will dampen
social morale.
The government has promised to take steps in the coming five
years toward breaking up monopolies, as mapped out in its 11th Five-Year Plan (2006-10). This is the
right place to start.
In discussing solutions to break up monopolies, anti-monopoly
legislation is often proposed, which would likely play a vital
role. Indeed, a viable and comprehensive legal framework would
equip the nation's anti-monopoly efforts with strong legal
support.
Given China's realities, the government can also play a significant
role in curbing the monopoly sectors from grabbing exorbitant
profits within existing legal framework.
Most of China's monopoly sectors are state-controlled. It is a
legacy of the highly centralized planned economy. This renders the
government regulators easier access to information and more
convenience in carrying out its supervisory duty.
One of the regulatory duties of the government lies in
preventing monopoly sectors from taking advantage of their market
position to overcharge consumers. A 2000 investigation by central
China's Hunan Province's price supervisory department revealed a
163 million yuan (US$20.37 million) overcharge by local power firms
to customers. A 2004 audit in central China's Henan Province found
its telecom sector overcharged consumers more than 100 million yuan
(US$12.5 million).
Regulators in those regions were keeping up. It shows that
technical barriers or lack of wisdom are not problematic and the
government can detach itself with monopolized interests only if it
gathers adequate political will.
Such a political commitment is indispensable in making the
country's anti-monopoly strategies.
Encouraging competition, for example, is the ultimate way of
breaking up monopolies. But the government sometimes sticks to
price controls to tackle the problem, as shown in the medical
service sector.
Such a methodology may encounter less pressure from monopolized
interests, but is less effective in the long run.
(China Daily May 19, 2006)